Let me start of the post by saying, New doesn’t always mean better. That said let’s move on to comparing them and you can make your own informed decision. I will not compare every little thing but I do hope it is enough.
|Reader’s Digest Complete Guide to Sewing||1976||2002|
|Number of Chapters||14||11|
|Sewing for Boys and Men||A whole section||2 projects|
The above charts gives a bit of info on the difference between the two books but here I’ll try to give you a bit more chapter by chapter or section. In the 2002 version the book is laid out in chapters versus the 1976 version has main sections that may or may not have a subsections so I’ll try to compare each part as best as I can.
Chapter 1: Reader’s Digest 2002 deals with Sewing Equipment and Fabrics whilst the 1976 calls it the Necessities of Sewing.
They both go over basic sewing equipment. RD02 (Readers’s Digest 2002) dedicates the least amount of pages to this subject and they also include fabric . When going over sewing equipment the notions are scattered about with captions labeling and explaining their uses.
RD76 shows far more notions and they are laid out in a more ordered fashion with captions again labeling and explaining their uses.
Here is an example for comparison. A tracing wheel and shears
Also as you can see RD02 uses pictures versus RD76 uses life like illustrations.
When it comes to sewing machines RD02 list and explains the different machines that can be found today while RD76 shows a general sewing machine and labels it different parts and it even show how a stitch is made, how to wind and insert both types of bobbins, and even how to check stitch tension.
RD02 also list and explains different types in this section but it not introduced until section 2 in RD76
Chapter 2 In RD02 this is Cutting and in RD76 this is section two called Patterns, Fabrics, and Cutting. They both go over how to measure the female figure. In RD76 this done with just a few illustrations and but RD2002 uses pictures. They both go over measuring the pattern and adjusting it for fit (in RD76 this is section 3 aka Portfolio Of Fitting Methods).
Again this is where RD76 introduces fabric. Now RD02 does list a lot of fabrics RD76 does try to show the few fabrics a lot better.
Chapter 3: In RD02 this is labeled as Stitches and Seams and here they go over hand stitches, machine stitches, seams, seam finishes, darts, gathering, shirring, smocking, and ruffles and flounces. In RD76 this info is introduced in section 4 called Construction Basics and it is laid out pretty much the same.
Chapter 4: RD02 Neckline Finishes and Collars and in RD76 this is Neckline and Collars.
This section is pretty much identical in both, but in RD76 on the last page after showing you how to construct a shirt collar with a separate band they do show you how to attach to garment whereas RD02 just leaves you with a finished collar and stand.
Chapter 5: RD02 Waistlines and Belts in RD76 this is Waistlines, Waistbands, and Belts
This section is almost identical in both versions but once again the newer version does lack some info which is given in older book. This includes how to mark and measure the waist seam and circumference, illustrations of various waistbands, different closures and more.
I’ll end it here for now and look forward to part 2 coming soon.
Until next time, happy sewing…